I use a MacBook since late 2007 when I realized that Linux, is not my OS choice and FreeBSD needs a lot of time to spend, in order to keep your ports up to date. My desktop needs are not that demanding. Email, web and terminal are my basic daily needs, although a word processor usually comes in handy every once in a while.
At that time the 13 inch 2.2GH Intel Core2Duo MacBook with 1Gb Ram looked very promising.
Bundled with Leopard, the successor of Tiger, it run really well and covered almost all of my needs. I used to get 4 hours of real battery time and I was very happy. Although I always though that the hardware was overpriced. I got so used to that thing that I decided to upgrade the memory because I wanted to run a couple of virtual machines as well. I must admit that with 2Gb Ram the MacBook became really fast. I started installing new software, got mac ports working too!
And then came Snow Leopard. I was a bit skeptical to upgrade because there weren’t many new features. But it turned out that this was a good thing. In fact, you could say that Snow Leopard was the perfect continuation of Leopard. The OS became much faster, more reliable and less memory hungry. It was for me the ultimate OS one could pay for.
In the mean time, Apple started making tons of money and saw their stock price go high, by selling cell phones. Well, they called them smartphones but if you think about it for a while they are just overpriced cell phones. Those cell phones were based on a closed source hybrid darwin kernel with many bugs. Apple thinks that this new type of software should be passed on to personal computers as well. So, OS X Lion was born…
Why Lion Sucks
Some features that supposedly will change the way you work:
Multi-Touch Gestures
It is so useless that I wouldn’t even mention anything about this. Except Apple who things that is so cool that it has to be the number one new feature in their web side about Lion.
Full-Screen Apps
That was something missing (?) Most OS can run an application in full screen and they don’t need to brag about it. With a Mac it is different because many applications refuse to resize properly in full screen mode. Unfortunately for Lion, and for you, if you try this you will soon end up searching how to escape from this mode. It is so annoying and complicated that I only used it once.
Mission Control
A better version of “expose”. Nothing fancy, but nice to have.
Mac App Store
This is hardly a Lion feature. The App Store is available for Snow Leopard as well.
Launchpad
I don’t really need a Iphone style application menu. But again it is good to have.
Resume
Here things begin to get ugly. You open your wordproccessor and suddenly the last document you were working on appears. Hey, I am not that lazy, if I need that document I will open it again. It really sucks though when I have to close it just because Apple thinks I will work on it again.
Some facts that will definitely change the way you work:
- If you have 2Gb of Ram then you can just forget about it. Lion does very bad memory management and you soon end up drained, swaping for some memory.
- Your battery will drain very quick. I have read a few discussions regarding how Lion needs better battery calibration. Sorry but this is BS. The only reason why the battery time is reduced is because your CPU will work more intensively and your load averages will increase. When this happens the CPU temperature also rises and as a result the fans start spinning like hell. And it all come down to higher energy consumption.
- Be prepared to use the disk utility quite often since you will have to repair disk permissions very often.
- If you happen to own a NAS (Network Area Storage) to store and share your documents you might experience some issues with Samba protocol. AFP seems to be working without problems.
- Generally, you will have to be more patient as it will take more time for your applications to load. But don’t worry you can always get to watch the apple mouse spinning ball while you wait. Sometimes they might even crash also.
to be continued … (till then I switched back to Snow Leopard)







Well in my case the partitioning failed and trashed my hard drive. Back to Snow Leopard for the iMac. I am tired of Mac’s and Apples arrogance. I will stick with the other PC options and when tge MAC dies I will not buy one again.
(I have MacBook Pro earlier 2011, 8Gb ram, …)
Mac OS X Lion is very heavy OS, Windows 7 and Windows 8 are more lite than it. I’ve tried guest Mac OS X Lion under host Mac OS X Lion on my MacBook… and it’s very slow (but works).
But about other things I more happy with this OS.
> Multi-Touch Gestures
ha! it very useful when you use track pad, but not mouse!
> Mac App Store
it is in system since Mac OS X Snow Leopard
> Launchpad
Firstly I think same as you, but is become more useful than plain application list with Launcher
> Resume
I agree with you, but you can disable completely or for specific applications. I use this methods.
http://osxdaily.com/2011/07/18/disable-mac-os-x-lion-resume-window-restore/
http://osxdaily.com/2011/07/31/disable-resume-specific-applications-mac-os-x-lion/
… You forget about reversed scroll direction. After this feature I can’t work correctly in Windows/FreeBSD/Linux first 2-3 minutes
I own a late 2006 macbook. I’ve recently upgraded to 2GB’s of RAM, and bought a new HDD, since the previous one died.
I’m now running OS X Lion 10.7.3, and I’m very happy with it, and guess what, it feels faster (and a lot smoother too!) than my PC configuration (i5 2400k, SSD, 4GB RAM, HD3870 Radeon graphics)!
I’m using it mainly for web browsing, and text editing (textmate, coda etc).
Flash videos are an issue when not in full screen, the cpu fan gets a bit loud. Other than that, it’s probably the best buy I’ve ever made, considering it’s been almost 6 years.
OS X Lion is, imho, great, but a new HDD and – at least – 2GB of RAM is a must have
I just upgraded my Hackintosh, a late 2006 with an ASUS P5B, Intel Core2Duo, 4GB Ram and Nvidia GeForce 7300 GT to 10.7.3 from 10.6.8
The performance is lacking compared to Snow Leopard.
Still I wouldn’t recommend it for a Macbook.
Multitouch seems to be a cheap version of Xorg’s multipointers. I haven’t set this up on FreeBSD but have on Linux.
The full screen applications are similar to what matchbox does with it’s environment when an application is launched.
You are right about all this new “features”. But … You are all missing the best feature of Lion: possibility to resize a window from any side of it.
Only for that feature I would choose Lion over Snow Leopard!
I tend to think that the problem is hardware related. Meaning that old Macbooks can not handle Lion. For example, my Hacintosh runs super fast with Lion and it is a 2006 model! Of course I have 8GiB of RAM and a fast HD with 64Mb of RAM.